Prepared for Presentation at the

Fulbright Institute Conference on International Affairs

University of Arkansas

April 5-6, 2001

 

A Decade of Post-Communism:

The Fate of Democracy in Eastern Europe

and the Former Soviet Union

 

 

Preconference Draft---March 26, 2001

 

Democracy and Counterinsurgency in Central Asia

 

 

Gregory Gleason

University of New Mexico  

Albuquerque, NM 87131   USA               

505-277-7391 (desk)   505-277-3161 (fax)              

Email:  gleasong@unm.edu        Website:  www.unm.edu/~gleasong

 

 

Abstract

 

A recent increase in insurgency and political instability is imperiling the modest gains of a decade of national consolidation in the states of Central Asia.  Confronted by religious and political extremism, terrorism, and national separatism, the governments of the region have redoubled security measures and imposed new constraints upon domestic political opposition.  The counterinsurgency measures instituted by the governments have the announced goal of neutralizing terrorists and bandits.  But the governments have cast a wide net, ensnaring legitimate critics and opponents as well as many perfectly innocent victims.  Surveying the five countries of Central Asia over the past decade, this paper analyzes progress in achieving the goals of popularly supported and accountable government.  The paper analyzes the rise of militant Islamic opposition to the governments as a factor constraining the governments’ reform and development strategies.  The paper concludes that the prospects for democratic reform in the region are less promising today than a decade ago.  At the same time, the paper argues that the rise of insurgency is also inclining the governments toward a new level of inter-state cooperativeness.  This new level of inter-state cooperation offers prospects for mitigating the most anti-democratic tendencies in the region.