November 10, 2000
INTRODUCTION
The pace of international change
at the start of the twenty-first century has overtaken time-honored institutions
such as the American university. The challenges for teaching, research,
and service that are posed by internationalization and globalization require
a new and more coherent response by universities. Those institutions
that position themselves to meet such challenges have much to gain.
Those that do not have much to lose. The University of New Mexico,
as an institution that has significant, but not unlimited, international
resources, is at a decision point. UNM can join those institutions
that are reorganizing and refocusing their resources to incorporate an
international dimension or it can lose its comparative advantages by failing
to act. The Committee believes that the UNM administration should
take forceful steps to insure that the University responds effectively
to the challenges of globalization by incorporating an international dimension
as part of its overall mission.
CURRENT RESOURCES
UNM currently engages in a variety
of international activities. Latin American studies traditionally
have been an area of excellence at UNM, and the Latin American and Iberian
Institute (LAII) is a nationally-ranked and federally-funded area center
that coordinates a variety of academic, research, and service activities,
including study-abroad programs in Latin America and Spain. The Office
of International Programs and Studies (OIPS) provides services for foreign
students, manages additional study-abroad programs, advises UNM students
and faculty on other opportunities such as Fulbright awards, and provides
services for the Russian, European, and Asian studies programs of the College
of Arts and Sciences. Both the LAII and OIPS conduct exchange programs
with foreign universities. The Office of Admissions is responsible
for handling admission of foreign undergraduate students. Admission
of foreign graduate students is handled by the Office of Graduate Studies.
Other significant international activities are conducted by UNM schools and colleges. In addition to the foreign area studies programs already mentioned, examples include the Festival of the Americas and the Institute of Arts of the Americas of the College of Fine Arts, Latin American Programs in Education of the College of Education, the Summer Program in Mexican Law and the International Transboundary Resource Center of the School of Law, the Latin American biology projects of the Department of Biology, the overseas study programs of the Honors Center, the School of Nursing's cooperative M.S. program for faculty in schools of nursing at three Mexican universities, collaborative overseas research projects by the Department of Physics and Astronomy, the German Summer School and Atlantic Bridge projects of the Department of Foreign Languages, the international programs of Continuing Education, and the many overseas research projects of the Department of Anthropology. Foreign holdings of the General Library are outstanding for Latin America and strong for Europe. Faculty with overseas experience and foreign language capability are found throughout the University.
CURRENT PROBLEMS
There is a lack of coordination
among the various units that engage in international activities, with the
exception of programs focusing on Latin America and Iberia. UNM's
overall international activity can be described as balkanized. Other
problems identified by the Committee include:
1) lack of development of international
and foreign area studies programs except those under the Latin American
and Iberian Institute,
2) relatively low numbers of foreign students
in comparison to peer institutions,
3) serious problems in the foreign student
recruitment and admission processes at both undergraduate and graduate
levels,
4) inadequate support structures for foreign
students and faculty,
5) relatively low numbers of UNM students
studying abroad,
6) lack of resources to support faculty
research and travel abroad,
7) lack of staffing support for international
and area studies other than LAII,
8) lack of access to information about
current and pending international activities
9) lack of a mechanism to coordinate international
activities.
10) lack of a clear institutional commitment
to global and international issues other than those involving Latin America
and Iberia.
RECOMMENDATIONS
The Committee considered a variety
of possible solutions for the problems it identified. It also discussed
various alternative models of organization of international activities
at several institutions known for excellence in international programs,
such as the University of Pittsburgh, the University of Washington (Seattle),
Duke University, and Michigan State University. The Committee also
considered at length the recent publication of the National Association
of State Universities and Land Grant Colleges,"Expanding the International
Scope of Universities", and incorporated a number of its recommendations
in this report.
The Committee debated the question of resources for internationalization and agreed that its recommendations should be posited on the assumption that new resources will be modest at best. In consequence, its recommendations assume that the first challenge will be to make the best use of existing resources, which in turn will position UNM to respond to international challenges incrementally and to innovate in seeking outside funding.
Recommendation 1. UNM should
make internationalization an integral part of the University's mission
and strategic plan.
Internationalization of the University
is not an important component of the most recent UNM mission statement,
UNM 2000, adopted by the Regents in 1995, except with reference to the
Western Hemisphere. The Administration should take steps to see that
a broader vision of the internationalization of UNM is incorporated in
future mission statements and strategic plans. By "internationalization"
is meant greater involvement of students in international education experiences,
the incorporation of international content in the curriculum, increasing
the numbers of foreign students and faculty, expanding the international
activity of faculty and professional staff, and assuring that international
research and scholarship permeate UNM's disciplines, interdisciplinary
programs, and professional schools. It should be stressed that internationalization
is an important means to promote diversity
at UNM.
Recommendation 2. UNM should provide
coordination and direction of its international activities through an administrative
reorganization and the appointment of an Associate Provost for International
Programs.
The Task Force recommends placing
all international activities under an associate or vice provost whose primary
responsibility is to coordinate international programs and activities at
UNM. This associate provost should be given line authority over all
international units and activities other than those conducted by schools
and colleges. Units or functions reporting to this office would be
of two types: international academic units, such as the LAII and another
unit to be proposed that would house other existing foreign area study
programs; and international service units, such an office for international
student services, an office for exchange and study abroad, CELAC
(Center for English Language and American Culture), and, possibly, an office
for international student recruitment and admission at both undergraduate
and graduate international admissions. The Associate Provost for
International Programs would assume the functions of, and therefore supersede,
the position of Director of OIPS (which would be eliminated). This
outcome is the equivalent of transforming the directorship of OIPS into
the associate provostship. Implications for the current service functions
of OIPS are addressed below.
Recommendation 3. UNM should
establish, under the new Associate Provost for International Programs,
a new Center for International Research and Studies (CIRS) to promote the
development of international research and the study of world areas other
than Ibero-America.
CIRS should provide support services
comparable to those provided to the Latin Americanist students and faculty
by the LAII. This new unit is conceived as an "incubator" that will
support and help generate outside funding for international and area studies
programs and for thematically-oriented international and global projects
that span disciplines and geographic areas. CIRS should also manage
study-abroad programs for areas other than Latin America and Iberia. CIRS
should begin with a modest investment through in-house recruitment of a
director from the UNM faculty, a grant-writer, clerical help, and reassignment
of existing personnel. CIRS would provide administrative support
for the existing Asian, European, and Russian studies programs, as well
as support for developing new projects on interdisciplinary global themes.
Successful aspects of the LAII operation could be replicated with the cooperation
of the LAII itself, which would be a sister unit. It should be noted
that the division of responsibility between the LAII and CIRS would replicate
the division of labor between the Department of Spanish and Portuguese
and the Department of Foreign Languages.
Recommendation 4. The support
of the international community at UNM (such as foreign students and faculty)
should be the primary function of a new unit called the Office of International
Student and Faculty Services (OISFS) that would replace OIPS and report
to the new Associate Provost for International Programs. This unit
would be staffed with current OIPS who provide international student services.
An office with the primary function
of serving foreign students would have a clear performance mandate, as
opposed to the very broad spectrum of international activities currently
under the OIPS. This change would restore the original character
of OIPS, which originally began as the Office of International Student
Services. OIPS activities in support of Asian, European, and Russian
studies should be moved to the new CIRS.
Recommendation 5. A new Office
of International Study Abroad and Student Exchanges (OISASE) should be
established and staffed with existing OIPS personnel.
This office would provide university-wide
coordination and publicity for study-abroad and exchange programs and be
charged with developing expanded opportunities for overseas study for the
student body at large, including opportunities for financial support.
The many specialized study abroad programs that already exist in other
units at UNM (such as the Honors Center, the LAII, Fine Arts, and the Law
School) would continue, but should work in collaboration with the new office
to avoid duplication of offerings.
Recommendation 6. Support
for international research and faculty development should be a specific
charge of the new Center for International Research and Studies.
The success of the LAII in achieving
faculty participation and recruitment results in considerable measure from
its programs of support for faculty research abroad and travel to professional
meetings. The Task Force recommends that a reasonable but significant portion
of the funds currently allocated to the Research Allocations Committee
be set aside for support of international research and be allocated by
a faculty committee of CIRS. Additional funding for faculty development
and program support activities should be obtained by applying to the U.S.
Department of Education's Title VI Undergraduate International Studies
and Foreign Languages grant program.
Recommendation 7. Mechanisms
should be introduced to insure faculty and student involvement in the new
Center for International Research and Studies.
Faculty involvement has been the
key to success of interdisciplinary units (such as the LAII) and therefore
must be initiated and maintained through specific mechanisms, such as a
policy committee of faculty members, a faculty committee with responsibility
for an international speakers program, and a faculty committee responsibility
for allocating research and support funds to faculty and students.
Each committee should have student representation. An international
studies student organization should be established and provided with a
modest budget for programs, which can then be augmented with ASUNM and
GPSA funds.
Recommendation 8. The new
Associate Provost for International Affairs should be given some type of
authority over international recruitment and admissions, the nature of
which should be recommended by a faculty/staff committee, based on an investigation
of procedures employed at universities with high success rates in enrolling
foreign students.
The committee finds that systematic
international recruitment is almost entirely lacking and should be initiated.
Bottlenecks in international admission at both undergraduate and graduate
levels are also a serious problem that must be addressed. The Committee
did not have a consensus on recommending a mechanism. A majority
felt that a new Office of International Recruitment and Admissions should
be established under the new Associate Provost and staffed ith current
admissions personnel. It was argued in opposition that this would
create problems with the regular admissions office and with the Office
of Graduate Studies. There was a consensus that whether or not the
current admissions personnel are placed directly under the Associate Provost
in a new office, the Associate Provost should be granted some type of authority
over international recruitment and admissions. The Committee did
agree that resolution of this issue requires investigation of arrangements
at more successful institutions, and recommends that a faculty\staff advisory
committee on international recruitment be appointed to assist the Associate
Provost in addressing international admissions and recruitment.
Recommendation 9. An International
Studies major and minor should be established, following the Latin American
Studies model, with administrative support provided by CIRS and academic
supervision provided by the College of Arts and Sciences.
The core language, area, and international
studies courses for such a degree already exist in Latin American, Asian,
European, and Russian studies, and in international studies fields such
as international economics and comparative politics. An interdisciplinary
supervisory committee should be named that includes representation from
these four areas and from international studies fields such as international
economics, international relations, comparative politics, and international
law).
Recommendation 10. Support
for grant development should be provided through CIRS with initial assistance
from the Office of Research Services (ORS).
Success in obtaining external funding
will be the key to the success of CIRS (as it has been for the LAII).
Grant support programs for area studies and international studies exist
in the federal government and in private foundations but have not been
tapped due to lack of support for project development and proposal writing.
The CIRS should have a grant writer and/or a director and executive officer
with grant preparation skills, so that the international and area studies
programs under its aegis can seek external support. Initial support
for grant development could be provided through the part-time loan of a
staff person from ORS.
Recommendation 11. UNM should
develops methods to give priority (other things being equal) in new faculty
hires to persons with international expertise.
The long-term growth of UNM's international
faculty resources will have to result from an incremental process of normal
faculty turnover and hiring. For the desired result to be obtained,
priority in hiring faculty with international expertise, other things being
equal, should be made official policy. Specific methods of implementing
the policy should be developed, such as including a faculty person with
international expertise on faculty search committees (similar to what has
been done to increase minority hiring).
MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE ON GLOBALIZATION,
INTERNATIONALIZATION, AND LATIN AMERICA
(Present and Voting to approve the
Report on November 9, 2000)
Gilbert W. Merkx (Chair), Latin American
and Iberian Institute
Rebecca Digman, Office of International
Programs and Services
Guillermina Engelbrecht, Latin American
Programs in Education
Gladis Maresma, Office of International
Technical Cooperation
Peter Pabisch, Foreign Languages
Lawrence Roybal, Outreach Services
Susan Tiano, Sociology
Jon M. Tolman, Spanish and Portuguese
SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS
1. UNM should make internationalization an integral part of the University's mission and strategic plan.
2. UNM should provide coordination and direction of its international activities through an administrative reorganization and the appointment of an Associate Provost for International Programs.
3. UNM should establish, under the new Associate Provost for International Programs, a new Center for International Research and Studies (CIRS) to promote the development of international research and study of world areas other than Latin America.
4. The support of the international community at UNM (such as foreign students and faculty) should be the primary function of a new unit called the Office of International Student and Faculty Services (OISFS) that would replace OIPS and report to the new Associate Provost for International Programs.
5. A new Office of International Study Abroad and Student Exchanges (OISASE) should be established and staffed with existing OIPS personnel.
6. Support for international research and faculty development should be a specific charge of the new Center for International Research and Studies.
7. Mechanisms should be introduced to insure faculty and student involvement in the new Center for International Research and Studies.
8. The new Associate Provost for International Affairs should be given some type of authority over international recruitment and admissions, the nature of which should be recommended by a faculty/staff committee, based on an investigation of procedures employed at universities with high success rates in enrolling foreign students.
9. An International Studies major and minor should be established, following the Latin American Studies model, with administrative support provided by CIRS and academic supervision provided by the College of Arts and Sciences.
10. Support for grant development should be provided through CIRS with initial assistance from the Office of Research Services (ORS).
11. UNM should develops methods to give priority (other things being equal) in new faculty hires to persons with international expertise.