TWO-YEAR COLLEGE MATHEMATICS PROGRAMS
AT THE MILLENNIUM
HIGHLIGHTS
OF
THE FINDINGS OF THE FALL, 2000
NATIONAL SURVEY
OF
COLLEGIATE MATHEMATICS DEPARTMENTS
AS THEY PERTAIN TO
TWO-YEAR COLLEGESPrepared By
Stephen B. Rodi
Austin Community College
Associate Survey Director for Two-Year Colleges
BACKGROUND
Once every five years since 1965, two-year colleges have participated in a survey of collegiate mathematics programs in the U.S. sponsored by the Conference Board of the Mathematical Sciences (CBMS) with support from the National Science Foundation (NSF). CBMS and the Survey Committee especially thanks the two principal collegiate undergraduate mathematics professional organizations for their help in gathering survey data, namely, The American Mathematical Association of Two-Year Colleges (AMATYC) and the Mathematical Association of America (MAA).
Here are some interesting facts about mathematics programs in two-year colleges taken from the CBMS2000 survey which was conducted in fall, 2000. The entire survey will be available in print from the American Mathematical Society (P.O. Box 6248, Providence, R.I., 02940-6248; e-mail ams@ams.org) about April 15, 2002. After about April 15, the reader should be able to access the complete survey document by using the URL "www.cbmsweb.org."
For fall, 2000, the survey was managed by professional statisticians in the survey unit at The University of North Carolina (Chapel Hill) who determined a stratified sample of 300 two-year colleges nationwide to receive the survey instrument. Of these, 179 (60%) returned the survey, from which national figures were projected. The CBMS Survey Committee used these projections in its regular five-year report/analysis.
For more information about the survey and its findings as they pertain to two-year colleges, contact Stephen Rodi, Associate Survey Director for Two-Year Colleges, at "srodi@austin.cc.tx.us."
=========================================================================
THE FACULTY
In fall, 2000 there were about 7000 full-time permanent faculty members in mathematics programs in two-year colleges in the U.S. This was an 8% drop from fall, 1995. Another 960 individuals taught as temporary full-time faculty, an almost 600% increase (yes, six-fold) from 1995.
About 49% of the full-time permanent faculty members in mathematics were women. This was the first time in 35 years of surveying that the proportion of men and women among the full-time permanent faculty was essentially equal.
About 13% of the full-time permanent faculty members were ethnic minorities. Ethnic minorities made up a higher proportion (20%) of the under-age-40 faculty than they did of the faculty as a whole.
The median age of the full-time permanent faculty in two-year college mathematics programs was 48. The average age rose slightly since 1995, from 47.2 to 47.6. The proportion of the full-time permanent faculty over age 54 rose to 27%.
The number of part-time faculty (over 15,500 when including about 750 part-time faculty who teach dual-credit courses and are actually paid by outside sources like school districts) was more than double the figure for full-time faculty and made up 69% of all mathematics faculty in two-year college programs. The proportional size of the part-time faculty, which had remained steady at 65% in 1990 and 1995, rose by 4 percentage points in fall 2000.
About 46% of all course sections in mathematics programs were taught by part-time faculty members. In addition, 52% of full-time permanent two-year college mathematics faculty members taught extra hours for extra pay at their own college, class sections which otherwise would have required additional part-time faculty teaching.
The part-time faculty teaching percentage varied by type of course, with part-time faculty members teaching 58% of remedial courses and 15% of mainstream calculus courses. The first number rose by 11 percentage points between 1995 and 2000, and the second dropped by 2 percentage points.
Selection patterns for the 572 new full-time permanent faculty hired academic year 2000-2001 showed unexpected characteristics. Only 13% of new hires had a doctorate as compared to 19% in 1995-1996. Only 8% were hired directly from graduate school compared to 30% in 1995. The percentage of new hires chosen from current part-time or temporary faculty nearly doubled to 34%. The percentage of new hires with a terminal bachelors degree jumped dramatically from 1% for academic year 1995-1996 to 19% for academic year 2000-2001.
ENROLLMENT
Enrollment in mathematics and statistics courses taught within mathematics programs at two-year colleges dropped from 1995 to 2000 by about 7.5%, even though over-all enrollment in two-year colleges had risen about 2% from 1994 to 1998, according to the most recent confirmed over-all enrollment data available from the Department of Education.
(Remediation programs managed separately from the mathematics program--for example, in a developmental studies division--are not included in this figure either for CBMS1995 or for CBMS2000. In fall, 2000 there were about 1,347,000 enrollments in two-year college mathematics program with another 118,000 enrollments in mathematics courses not part of the mathematics program. These latter were mostly enrollments in remedial mathematics courses in separate developmental studies departments.)
Two-year and four-year schools each ended the decade with mathematics enrollments at 1990 levels. But they followed very different paths to this result. Four-year enrollments fell from 1990 to 1995 and rebounded in 2000 to their earlier levels. Two-year mathematics enrollments rose sharply from 1990 to 1995 but by 2000 had fallen back to 1990 levels.
Enrollment in mathematics courses outside of the mathematics program (e.g., in a developmental studies department) continued to decline and at a rate faster than overall mathematics program enrollment (23% versus 7.5%).
Enrollment in remedial classes accounted for over half (55%) of mathematics program enrollment in two-year colleges. (This figure includes only remedial courses supervised by a mathematics program, not remedial enrollment in separate developmental studies programs.)
Remedial level courses, which lost 37,000 enrollments, accounted for the largest segment of the mathematics program enrollment decline. This was an almost 5% remedial mathematics enrollment drop within mathematics programs from 1995 to 2000.
A new course to which some college algebra enrollment likely migrated since 1995 is Introductory Mathematical Modeling. It was offered in fall, 2000 at 12% of two-year colleges.
The calculus segment, which includes both mainstream and non-mainstream calculus, had the largest percentage enrollment decrease (18%) from 1995 to 2000. This decline was about 23,000 students. Non-mainstream calculus was particularly hard hit with a 38% drop in enrollment in the first term course. (Mainstream refers to the calculus courses which lead on to more advanced mathematics courses such as Differential Equations, and are taken by, among others, engineering, physics, and science majors.)
Mathematics courses showing enrollment percentage increases from 1995 to 2000 were Elementary Statistics (3%), Mathematics for Liberal Arts (13%) and Mathematics for Elementary School Teachers (12.5%). These were the only courses to show increases.
Just 14% of two-year college mathematics programs offered a high-school-level geometry course in fall 2000, a 3 percentage point drop since 1995. This continues a steady decline, which began in 1980, in geometry enrollment at two-year colleges.
PLACEMENT, PEDAGOGY AND CURRICULUM
Virtually all two-year colleges with mathematics programs offered diagnostic or placement testing. About 98% had a mathematics lab or tutorial center.
Locally written placement test materials were used in 99% of colleges while commercial tests came from American College Testing (ACT), the Educational Testing Service (ETS) and a variety of other test providers. The first two commercial sources were used, respectively, by 30% and 34% of two-year colleges.
On a comparative level, in fall 2000 two-year colleges were much more likely than four-year colleges or universities to require placement testing of their entering or first-time students (98% versus 49%) or to enforce mandatory course placement based on the test (67% to 47%). The gap also is large with regard to a required visit with an advisor before enrolling in a mathematics course, 79% at two-year colleges and 60% at four-year colleges.
In fall 2000, the average section size in two-year college mathematics courses continued the downward trend begun ten years earlier, ending the decade with an average section size of 23.7 students. The average section size in 1995 was 25.5 and in 1990 was 27.8 students.
The predominant instructional modality continued to be the standard lecture method. However, the graphing calculator was widely used in all courses beginning with College Algebra. For College Algebra, the change from 1995 to 2000 in the percent of course sections using graphing calculators was huge: 38% in 1995 to 74% in 2000.
The percentage of sections in all three levels of mainstream calculus using group projects and writing components increased , although the rate of increase was not as great as was seen earlier in the reform movement between 1990 and 1995. The use of graphing calculators rose 13 percentage points, 11 percentage points, and 6 percentage points, respectively, in these three courses.
Fewer than 1% of mathematics class sections were offered via television in 1995 and only 2.5% in 2000 were described as using distance learning. Among high enrollment courses, College Algebra had 6.7% of sections offered via distance learning and Elementary Statistics had 5.8%.
During the two-academic-year period of 1999-2000 and 2000-2001, 65% of all two-year colleges offered a pre-calculus/elementary functions course, a nearly twenty percentage point increase compared to 1994-1995 and 1995-1996. The percentage of two-year colleges offering a combined college algebra/trigonometry course during that same two-year period almost doubled to 32%.
About half of two-year colleges offered a special mathematics course for pre-service K-8 teachers in either academic year 1999-2000 or 2000-2001. Fewer than a quarter assigned a faculty member to coordinate pre-service K-8 teacher education.
In comparison to 1995, in fall 2000 an increasing percentage of two-year colleges, but still no more than 50%, offered specialized courses such as Linear Algebra, Mathematics for Liberal Arts, and Mathematics for Elementary School Teachers.
DUAL ENROLLMENT
CONTINUING EDUCATION
SUPERVISION STRUCTURE FOR PROGRAMS
WORK CONDITIONS
PROGRAM PROBLEMS
In fall 2000, dual enrollment courses--courses often taught on a high school campus by a high school teacher and for which a student received both high school and college credit--made up about 14% (1726 of 11,995) of all college algebra, precalculus, and calculus course sections at two-year colleges. About 61% of two-year college mathematics programs reported full control over the selection of instructors for dual enrollment courses.
The number of institutions and mathematics programs requiring some form of continuing education or professional development for full-time permanent faculty almost doubled from 20% in 1995 to 38% in 2000.
In fall, 2000 a traditional mathematics or mathematics/computer science department was found in fewer than half (43%) of the two-year colleges with mathematics programs, and 10% of these were multi-campus departmental arrangements. More common was a division structure, where mathematics program administration was combined with science or other disciplines.
In 29% of two-year colleges, remedial/developmental mathematics courses were administered separately from the mathematics program. This was almost exactly the same percentage as in 1995.
For the first time, in fall 2000 essentially all full-time permanent faculty had a computer or terminal in their office, up to 99% from 76% in 1995. On the other hand, there was an 8 percentage point increase in the number of part-time faculty who needed to share a desk with two other people (three or more to a desk), up to 51%.
More mathematics program heads (62%) classified too much need for remediation as the most important problem faced by their mathematics program. Low student motivation and the need to use too many part-time faculty were second and third.
ACADEMIC YEAR TOTAL MATH ENROLLMENT IN TWO-YEAR COLLEGES
Summary.
Each academic year, there are almost 3 million enrollments in mathematics courses at two-year colleges. These account for about 46% of all academic year undergraduate collegiate mathematics enrollments.
_______________________________________________________________________
The analysis which supports the statement.
The CBMS2000 report contains a section on the ratio of academic year enrollment to fall enrollment for various kinds of schools. In 1995 and earlier, this was taken to be "2." Double the fall to get academic year. There seems to have been a significant change in that regard,
especially for four year schools, in fall, 2000, as a result of almost all schools moving to a semester (rather than quarter) system between 1995 and 2000. The multiplier respectively for academic 1999/2001 as reported in CBMS2000 are:
Four
Year School Math Departments: 1.84
Four
Year School Stat Departments: 2.18
Two
Year School Math Programs: 2.01
The following calculates a mathematics and statistics (but not computer science) total ACADEMIC year enrollment based on the fall, 2000 data, using the multiplier above. It includes mathematics and statistics taught in math departments, statistics taught in statistics departments, and (for two-year colleges) mathematics courses (mostly remedial) taught outside of math programs (e.g., in developmental studies departments). Fall enrollment numbers can be found in the printed CBMS2000 report in Table SE.1, except for the "outside program" enrollment number for two-year colleges which is in Table TYR.15.
| Fall, 2000 | Multiplier | Academic 2000-2001Estimated | |
| 4-Year Math Department | 1,785,000 | 1.84 | 3,284,000 (including stat) |
| 4-Year Stat Dept | 74,000 | 2.18 | 161,320 |
| 2-Year Math Program Outside Program |
1,465,000 | 2.01 | 2,944,650 |
| Grand Total Academic Year | 6,389,960 | ||
| Ratio of Two-Year College to Total | 46% |